AI Retail Media Buying: Are We Handing the Keys to the Bots Too Soon?

I recently noticed something strange while selling items on Facebook Marketplace: automated buyers sending automated messages, met by my own automated seller responses. It got me thinking about a much bigger trend happening in retail media right now.

In this episode, I unpack the rapid rise of objective-based, AI-driven retail media buying and share the results of a LinkedIn poll I ran to find out what advertisers really think about handing campaign decisions over to algorithms. While automation promises efficiency, many marketers are raising important questions about transparency, control, incrementality, and long-term brand building. Are we removing friction from advertising, or removing humans from the process altogether?

Timeline

[00:00] The Facebook Marketplace experience that sparked a bigger question about automation

[01:07] How objective-based, AI-driven retail media buying mirrors the "bots talking to bots" phenomenon

[01:45] Results from my LinkedIn poll: what advertisers really think about AI-powered media buying

[04:00] Why automation may struggle to drive true incrementality, according to commerce media leaders

[04:40] Retailer bias, "ROAS jail," and the measurement challenges facing AI-driven ad platforms

[05:15] The risk of optimizing for short-term performance at the expense of brand equity

[06:00] The question I'm still wrestling with: are we removing friction, or removing ourselves?

Links & Resources